Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers in History

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers of All Time

The Premier League has witnessed many players who excelled at penalties, showing calm and accuracy under pressure. Leading this list is Alan Shearer with 56 penalty goals, followed closely by Yaya Touré, who holds a perfect conversion record. Other names like Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane are also celebrated for their consistency. Young talents such as Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland are continuing this tradition, combining skill and nerves to become some of the best penalty takers in Premier League history.

Scoring from penalties remains one of the most dependable ways to find the net, and several forwards have made their mark through this method. It takes precision and mental strength to score when the spotlight is on you, and these players have proven their ability time and again. Here is our ranking of the top 10 Premier League penalty takers based on their records.

• 10. Bukayo Saka – Arsenal, 2019–Present, 12 penalties scored
• 9. James Beattie – Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke City, 1998–2010, 16 penalties scored
• 8. Callum Wilson – Bournemouth, Newcastle United, West Ham, 2014–Present, 16 penalties scored
• 7. Erling Haaland – Manchester City, 2022–Present, 20 penalties scored
• 6. Danny Murphy – Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, Fulham, 1997–2013, 18 penalties scored
• 5. Harry Kane – Tottenham Hotspur, 2012–2023, 33 penalties scored
• 4. Cole Palmer – Manchester City, Chelsea, 2021–Present, 18 penalties scored
• 3. Matt Le Tissier – Southampton, 1992–2002, 25 penalties scored
• 2. Yaya Touré – Manchester City, 2010–2018, 11 penalties scored
• 1. Alan Shearer – Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle United, 1992–2006, 56 penalties scored

Profiles of the Best Penalty Takers

10. Bukayo Saka (Arsenal)

After missing a crucial penalty in the UEFA Euro 2020 final, Bukayo Saka transformed into a dependable penalty taker. With a 92% success rate, he has scored 12 out of 13 attempts in the Premier League, becoming one of Arsenal’s leading spot-kick specialists.

9. James Beattie

James Beattie was a reliable marksman across multiple clubs including Southampton and Everton. He scored 16 penalties in 17 tries, missing only once in a 2006 game that didn't affect his team’s victory.

8. Callum Wilson

Callum Wilson has maintained composure from the spot since his days at Bournemouth. The striker has converted 16 penalties for several Premier League teams, boasting a 94% success rate despite a rare miss against Cardiff City.

7. Erling Haaland (Manchester City)

Erling Haaland has been prolific from the penalty spot, netting 20 goals from 23 attempts. His only misses include one against Sheffield United, yet he remains one of the Premier League’s deadliest finishers.

6. Danny Murphy

Danny Murphy, a midfielder known for his precision, missed just one penalty during his Premier League career. That miss came against Manchester City in 2008, but his overall conversion rate stands at an impressive 95%.

5. Harry Kane

Harry Kane scored 33 penalties from 37 attempts while at Tottenham Hotspur, making him one of the top spot-kick scorers. Although his conversion rate is about 89%, his reputation as a reliable penalty taker is well-earned.

4. Cole Palmer

Cole Palmer had a near-perfect penalty record until recently, scoring 18 out of 19 attempts for Manchester City and Chelsea. His calmness in front of goal makes him a promising figure among current penalty takers.

3. Matt Le Tissier

Matt Le Tissier, often called “Le God,” converted 24 of his 25 penalty attempts while playing for Southampton. His remarkable accuracy made him one of the most feared penalty takers in Premier League history.

2. Yaya Touré

Yaya Touré is the only player on this list to never miss a penalty in the Premier League, scoring 11 from 11 attempts with Manchester City. His technique and composure set a standard for midfielders taking penalties.

1. Alan Shearer

Alan Shearer tops the list with 56 penalties scored, the highest in Premier League history. Despite missing 10 or more spot kicks, his total goals from penalties remain unmatched, reflecting his status as one of England’s greatest strikers.

Penalty Takers Stats Summary

• Bukayo Saka: 223 appearances, 59 goals, 12 penalties, 92% conversion
• James Beattie: 270 appearances, 90 goals, 16 penalties, 94% conversion
• Callum Wilson: 267 appearances, 94 goals, 16 penalties, 94% conversion
• Erling Haaland: 129 appearances, 109 goals, 20 penalties, 87% conversion
• Danny Murphy: 417 appearances, 66 goals, 18 penalties, 95% conversion
• Harry Kane: 320 appearances, 213 goals, 33 penalties, 89% conversion
• Cole Palmer: 111 appearances, 46 goals, 18 penalties, 95% conversion
• Matt Le Tissier: 270 appearances, 101 goals, 24 penalties, 96% conversion
• Yaya Touré: 230 appearances, 62 goals, 11 penalties, 100% conversion
• Alan Shearer: 441 appearances, 260 goals, 56 penalties, 84% conversion

FAQs

• Who is the Premier League's greatest penalty taker?Alan Shearer holds the top spot as the Premier League’s best penalty scorer.
• Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 Premier League penalty takers?Yes, Haaland ranks 7th on the all-time list.
• Who are the top three Premier League penalty takers?Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier lead the list.
• Where does Erling Haaland stand among EPL penalty takers?He is placed 7th in the rankings.